So, Villa 2.0 is up and running and we’re finally starting to get some sense of what we’re working with. And as we’d hoped, it could be pretty good. Villa have gotten faster and younger, and most likely better. Wins have started accruing, one each in the Premier League, the Champions League, and Carabao Cup.
I saw a line that if Villa had known Jackson, Manzambi, Suzuki and Mbaye were coming in May, we’d have all been very excited, Villa staff included. And it looks as though their scouting and spending may have been on the mark.
Jackson is better on the ball than Ollie, strong and has better pace. Manzambi has already shown Rogers-like flashes and perhaps even greater tactical flexibility. Gomes is racking up strong numbers for his position and showing intelligence. Suzuki is somewhat of a revelation whose distribution definitely is an upgrade on Martinez’s, and his shot-stopping is looking to be at the same level. He’s growing in confidence commanding his area. Mbaye? Definitely got the quality and quick feet and showing good decision-making. Garnacho appears to have been relegated to an emergency back-up role. Talk of a January move for him doesn’t seem at all far-fetched.
Then you throw in Madjo, Alysson, Hemmings, Ruggeri, and Goretzka. Madjo, we’ll be waiting to see how he adapts to league play. Alysson is fast and tidy and doesn’t lack for confidence, either. Much better than bringing on Bailey. Since I was traveling, I didn’t see enough of Ruggeri in my catch-up viewing to render a real verdict, but given he’s been called up to the Italian side to deputize, you’d have too think he’s a decent player. Hemmings? Kid looks to have a real future.
Matches
Against Spurs, we finally got a league run-out with Jackson, Manzambi and Gomes together, and you can see why Emery values versatility: it allowed him tactical flexibility along with a mix of old and new heads. McGinn and Buendia were nominally ‘wide’ but inverted and narrow. No out-and-out winger. Manzambi with what often looked like a free or floating role, coming deep, wide, getting into the box and then combining with Jackson. More direct and central play, often a 4-2-1-2-1 or a 4-2-2-2. It gave Spurs’ midfield problems. With Suzuki thwarting Spurs’ early dominance, Villa were able to pounce and then build on it.
In time, the side may well be capable of breaking more effectively than the previous version, especially with improved distribution from Suzuki. The Jackson goal illustrated this perfectly.
The Coventry cup tie showed another version of the side and obviously could be considered a league match. There we saw Abraham lead the line, bag two, and Ross get another header. Hemmings and Mbaye wide showed a more traditional 4-2-3-1 setup, with both getting assists. Hemmings’ was a particularly cultured ball to set Abraham in. Mbaye’s assist with corner was a good delivery for Barkley who made no mistake, and Mbaye was a lively threat.
But it was against now-familiar Brugge where Villa finally got on track, and once again in the opening European fixture. First goal was a funny one, given Pau carried 50-60 yards to lay it off for McGinn who then stroked in a trademark curler to the far post. The second goal was interesting for how Jackson coolly backheeled to Gomes, who did a lot to wriggle free and set up Buendia. Jackson’s goal showed pace, strength, composure and quality. I hate saying it, but Ollie would not have scored that one or the one against Spurs. In the moment it seemed like window dressing, but Wan-Bissaka’s handball turned it into a winner. And it was another very direct goal with Pau pinging it to Jackson who ran on to it, cleverly evaded the keeper, held off defenders and slotted into the empty net.
So Villa have seemingly found their scoring boots, by and large.
If anything’s concerning, Villa seem a bit porous at the back. Some of it’s been bad luck, some of it’s being a step slow, some of it’s self-inflicted. At times Wan-Bissaka has looked comfortable, at others, not so much. Harwood-Bellis clearly is being worked in slowly. Before he was injured Maatsen was starting to look like he’d raised the defensive side of his game. And likewise, before he was injured, Pau had begun looking as comfortable as we’ve seen him. Konsa is looking to have been a bit of a loss regarding his pace and awareness, but we’ll see how the line settles down.
At the end of the day, winning 3-2 is pretty much the same as 1-0, but you would like to see clean sheets and being able to see out games where there aren’t many chances. 3-2 is fine when you’re scoring, but we all know often as not that seasons are defined by grinding out the 1-0s. I’ll take 3-1s all day, but Coventry could’ve had more. Forest, you hate that we were all over the shop at the back after Maatsen went out.
Funny thing, three goals in each victory against widely varying opposition, and 10 overall in four matches. A very good return, but there’s the six against to balance that out.
Overall Thoughts
Given that the opening slate of matches ended up constituting our preseason, it’s not been bad, though I’m still a bit upset about the Forest game and how that played out. Not only was it a lost point, maybe even three, but it was the rare occurrence where a poor professional foul injured a player, handed Forest an advantage, and undoubtedly influenced the outcome. It just wasn’t right in terms of sporting fairness and I don’t disagree with Emery’s red-card assessment.
Not much to argue about with the other results. Brighton and Arsenal were both tough opponents to open against given the upheaval, and Brighton’s handling of Arsenal casts our opener in a new light. Hull was disappointing but probably not terribly surprising. The Forest match, well, the less said the better. I’d have liked coming out of that and Hull with at least four points if not six. But again, context.
We’ve now had most of the newcomers make appearances and even if they’re not really integrated yet, they’ve managed to come together enough, and seem to be have enough football smarts to get the gist of Emery’s system. I’m okay with the timing of the break on the heels of our first league win and the fact it’s longer than usual. Gives everyone a chance to take a breath and spend more time together. Those on international duty are getting minutes, and Jackson has scored again for Senegal.
What comes next could well define our season, though. With a heavy slate of league and CL fixtures lined up, Villa will need everyone and will have to put the ‘coming together’ mindset behind them. Brentford, Fenerbahce, Newcastle, Viking, City, Bournemouth, Fulham, Barcelona, and Man U over the course of a month is a big ask. There’s opportunity in there, though, and we should have just about everyone available at some point during that run barring any setbacks. The only truly frightening fixture is the trip to Spain. We’ll soon find out how resilient the side really are.
The upside is that we’ve won two on the trot and bagged six in the process. Lots of room for improvement over 90 minutes, but there are goals in the side.
I could well end up eating these words, but once again I’m going to applaud Emery & Co. for being bold in the face of massive disruption and accepting the challenge of transforming the squad. On the one hand, they didn’t have much choice, but they’ve embraced the young talent on hand, and have likewise looked for the same profile on incomings.
They didn’t panic. They could’ve played it safer.
Turnover like this summer’s could unravel many clubs and managers, but I think it plays to Emery’s strengths. This is now truly his side and he’s got a lot of raw talent to mold. I’m only guessing, but my feeling is that this is an energizing moment for him. Having shown what he can do with an inherited side, he now gets to put his stamp on the club in a foundational way.
Without Purslow involved, the business in the wake of the Rogers windfall was guided by philosophy, structure, and a keen awareness that the profile of the side had to change and not just in terms of age. Having gone out and gotten Hemmings, Madjo, and Alysson, Villa showed the kind of anticipatory thinking that’s allowed Brighton and Brentford to stay competitive. Jackson, Manzambi, Suzuki, and Mbaye were all on others’ radar, but Villa were willing and able to do the deals.
Early days, but the players seem to fit together. It looks and feels like there’s coherence to it all.
Over to you.
And Then Villa Started Winning


Korean Villa…I found you amid the sea of bots trying to register. You’re good to go now, nice to see you.
Speaking of bots…if you’ve registered and not been approved, I beg for your patience. I’ve been working through a backlog of 5,000 pending registrations.
I may have mistakenly deleted a legitimate registration or two, so if you have registered and not been able to post, do try again.
Get those bots spanked. Bring in some more talking heads.
Excellent resume of Villa’s season so far John. I’m looking forward to improved results as team players return from injury and become available. I’ll be interested to see how Goretzka performs as he’s the only one we’ve not seen yet.
Manzambi could be named as Young Talent of the Year at the Ballon d’Or ceremony next month. An exciting prospect indeed. And if Gomes and Kamara strike up an understanding, it will provide defensive protection and reduce the goals against column.
With Jacko, Madjo, Alysson, Suzuki and Mbaye logging into Unai’s system, our future is looking exciting. We’re going to need everyone available for those 9 games mentioned above in the coming month.
So here is the whole sordid story of Citeh’s cheating from the horses mouth:
https://www.premierleague.com/en/news/4727779/premier-league-statement-manchester-city-fc/
Guilty on a monumental scale.
Yeah, that’s much bigger than what I thought. They should be expelled.
But what does “expelled” mean? Expelled from the PL? The EFL? England? I’d favor:
1. An ongoing points penalty for the length of time (9 years?) that the malfeasance went on. Maybe 25 points per season. Starting 25 years in the hole every season will make it almost impossible to finish near the top of the table and get into Europe.
2. A two-year ban on new signings.
3. A fine of the amount of the accounting cheats to be distributed among all the teams in the PL during those years.
A mere fine will be pocket change for the Emerati. A one-time points deduction will be overcome quickly. And the teams harmed by the crimes should get some recompense.
Oh, to be honest I don’t really know. I’m thinking of the ‘death penalty’ they handed out in college football. I’ll say more in a separate note due to how things get narrow on mobile.
PDX,
What’s discouraging to me is that I’m already seeing a bunch of hedging. What City has meant to the Premier League and global success. What City have done for Manchester. And if people are saying things like this already, and I’m also reading of disagreement among PL sides (who may or may not have dirty hands themselves) then I fear for anything commensurate.
But £1 billion pounds worth of cheating that’s fueled the arms race ruining the game has to be dealt with severely.
I think Mansour should be declared unfit. I agree with a continuing points deduction, but then they shouldn’t be able to take places or push anyone else down. The problem is that the EFL can’t be forced to take City, just the three naturally relegated teams. Otherwise I’d put them at the bottom of League Three with a large and ongoing deduction.
If they simply get relegated, they’ll be back up next year, so all players should be released from contracts. 25 points is eight wins and a draw, so they wouldn’t be able to win anything or qualify for Europe, most likely, but they would displace other teams below them.
Yes, reparations and the club has to be so hobbled that there’s no way back for at least a decade. Titles stripped, all of it. It has to be a line in the sand.
Build a book made of concrete and consequences, then have a baseball pitcher hurl it at them.
Reparations for all affected parties ie every team that’s player a PL season since the first year of the cheating. And they should be thrown out and banned from the league for a number of seasons (maybe the same number of years that they were cheating?)
They’ve knowingly given themselves a massive leg-up while looking the other teams dead in the face and pretending everyone is playing the same rules…cheaters.
It has to be a huge financial penalty and a sporting penalty that tries to offer a sense of justice to every other club that has been affected.
However, as you say, the immediate hedging and “let’s be realistic, they’re an important club” is not very reassuring.
I would guys that once Asterisk*FC get their heads around the fact that they have to take some sort of punishment, they’ll come to a deal with the league and the rest of the Sky 6, so that there’s a symbolic punishment but they don’t have to start again from where they were in 2009
It ended Sevilla 1-3 Villa this evening. An enjoyable watch. Villa controlled the game with the exception of 10 minutes after HT during which Sevilla took the lead. Due entirely to the HT changes disrupting our play. Sevilla then made plenty of changes and likewise it affected their rhythm.
Nacho got on the score sheet like he did against Southampton behind closed doors last week. Nice goal from Barks and a delightful effort from the kid Jenner.
Sevilla are currently 5th in La Liga so it was a good fight back by our boys. No idea how many first teamers were missing from their line up but we were missing many on international duty.
Couldn’t watch in the US. 🙁 How many of the injured players featured? Madjo?
We saw everyone of the injured group except Goretzka who wasn’t even on the bench so obviously not ready yet. Maatsen never travelled to Spain so he’s still out. Madjo came on during the 2nd half and looked sharp. Pau came on at HT. A kid called Bloomfield played LB after HT. He replaced a kid called Fortes who took a bit of a pasting first half from his winger. Bogey at RB 1st half, Wan-Bissaka at RB 2nd half. Kamara and Gomes in the pivot to start with. Bogey moved there 2nd half.
That’s got rid of the international break and we can now get back to matters Aston Villa. Seems all of our players have returned without significant injuries which is all I’m concerned about given the situation of 4 gruelling games at 3 day intervals. It’s going to be 2 games per week until the next international break so we’ll need everyone available.
Brentford on Sat. Failed to beat them 3 times last season. Here’s hoping we nail them at the first attempt this time round.
Seems Scotland flogged SJM mercilessly over the break. It will be interesting to see how Unai deals with the problem. Team selection this weekend will tell us plenty.
Sweden also flogged Lindelof to death. As captain, he’s played the full game in each of their 4 fixtures. Like SJM, not one of the younger legs but at least playing in the back line requires less energy than needed in the engine room. These two would be my main concerns.
My main activity during international breaks is checking to see if Scotland finally give Ginny a game off, alas not this one. I guess he’ll play 70 minutes for us tomorrow then get hooked. And it’ll be like that for the next month as we’re 2 games a week until the next internationals…
On the plus side, lots of minutes for Manzambi, including an extended training session against 10 man Scotland (where Ginny was forced to do 2 mens’ running😤)
Revving up for today’s game. Off down to VP shortly. Looking forward to seeing a strong line up and strong bench. Unai has options. And we do owe Brentford one for last season’s results. COYVB.
In an airport, won’t be able to watch. Hopefully reasonably cohesive and a bit of a wildcard.
Mings blooper, a few quick passes and they score from the dee.
PingPong. Villa scamper up the pitch and Jackson scores another snap goal that Ollie probably would have fluffed. Brentford look organised and compact and together. Villa look more direct with little messing about – except for Mings cockup.
Very much to and fro. Their goalie made a WN1 type save in the last seconds of the game to keep it at 1-1 for HT. Mings has had a few shaky moments with the ball at his feet – but then he is a destroyer first and a creator last. Ruggeri shown a few good moments. Still think he could be a reasonable LCB.
Wan Bisakka for Ruggeri??
Their dangerous number 7 has to go off – but then Chopper Cash did mangle him late in the first half.
68 minutes – Villa getting scrappy.
SJM right foot curler from the left.
Their centre half walks through our defence to score. BUGGERBUMS!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Their callum wilson on for last 5 minutes. He is a coventry git who hates Villa!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Flipping heck. Last kick of the game was a clearance on the half way line by Suzuki.
A draw was fair. Brentford were a more compact punchy and cohesive side than work in progress transitional Villa. They got away with more dirty stuff than Villa and their goalkeeper had to pull off a few worldies to keep them in the game. I see Villa as having a far higher ceiling than brentford once they gell.
But hey – we didn’t get this point last season.
Two points dropped for me 656. But I do think many folks will say it was a point well gained. After all, Brentford are no mugs. Had we taken our chances, it would have been a heavy defeat for a useful Bees team. First Buendia skied one over the bar. Then Jacko did the same. The best chance fell to SJM when it looked easier to score than miss but their keeper was brilliant.
I was still cursing Tyro for giving them the opening goal with his awful pass when Jacko popped up at the other end with a sublime finish. Must agree, I don’t think Ollie would have scored that one. Jacko is a baller and he’s quick. Just my type.
When SJM got us in front I thought we’d get the points. But in the EPL there are no guarantees. Shame we let their CB stroll through our defence for their second.
Disappointed we let it slip but much encouraged by our new squad. Mbaye showed lightning speed chasing one through ball. Highly impressive. With Alysson down the right we now have threats both sides. And in Mbaye, the electric pace we’ve been missing for several seasons.
Brentford didn’t come and park the bus. They had a go. It made for an entertaining game. But FFS, why did Pawson let them get away with so much fouling. No way past any of their players, if we did so it was instant chop ’em down stuff. Game stats show they committed 24 fouls. With less than 50% possession, that’s one every two minutes. Dirty bastards.
Just landed. Saw a bit of the first half (both goals), and did note the fouls anytime someone received in middle 2/3 position.
Gonna guess it’s easy to say Konsa and why Arse wanted him. We saw all the wobbles and lack of forward initiative, but he did cover well at the back with pace. Lindelof was never anyone’s #1/2 out there long term but I’ll have to watch.
Shipping too many goals. We are not defensively secure. Whether it’s the lack of cover from the holding pivot or just poor passing at the back or even a lack of tackling technique. Dunno. May be a mixture of all 3. One for Unai to solve.