• Login
    • Register
  • AVL Blog
  • Match Previews
  • Match Reviews

Ever-Changing Villa and Super Cup Optimism

Posted by John Clark | Aug 13, 2026 | AVL Blog, Match Reviews | 19

Ever-Changing Villa and Super Cup Optimism

I’ve not had a lot to say lately, mainly due to other commitments. There’s also the fact that a World Cup summer makes the usual close season slightly surreal. I’ve held off saying much because I’ve not really known what to make of it all. I’ve caught bits and pieces of the preseason games, need to go back and watch again, but with absentees, familiar faces gone, so many of the youth on the pitch..You’re just not sure what you’re watching.

Having lost Morgan Rogers and Youri Tielemans, I’ve had a bit of fear for the upcoming season. People offer me congratulations on last season, asking whether we’ll struggle in this one. I’ve not really had a good answer. Well, not one with a lot of conviction either way. I’d throw Onana in, too, but given how patchy his fitness has been, it’s not quite the same. Very useful when fit, not so much when’s away recovering.

On the other hand, we did bank good money, and the club have spent it getting younger and faster. Manzambi? I like what I’ve seen, which is a very limited sample, and if he truly is a direct replacement for Rogers, it might work. Obviously he’s nowhere near a bargain buy, but he is strong and explosive and well regarded. And we can’t forget Rogers was definitely in and out of form. And when he was out of it, it was really poor. If Manzambi is a more consistent player, it might be a net plus.

Youri? For me that’s the tougher one. Calm, composed, and always oozing quality on the ball. Most of the good things went through him, especially when he got between the lines. Is Joao Gomes good enough? Again, I don’t have enough of a sampling to have a meaningful opinion.

Garnacho? Well, Emery loves a project, and from a physical standpoint the kid has all the tools. But he’s obviously not been right in the head. When he’s found in space with a direct line to goal, he’s a serious threat. Has it been coaching and systems? Dunno. I suppose we’ll find out. I wasn’t in love with the rumors, but he’s here now and we know Emery won’t hesitate to make sure clauses aren’t met if he’s not working out.

But then the Super Cup came along. I was kind of dreading this one…The condensed run of games, being in Asia, the usual chopping and changing, the lack of familiar foundations, the youth coming in and out. Had no idea how PSG would approach it, and it became clear they weren’t treating it like a training session. This is a side that likes to win.

And Villa acquitted themselves really well. I was almost shocked, to be honest. Wasn’t perfect, of course, still looking a bit unfamiliar with the various combinations, rust and the like, but they basically went toe to toe with the best side in Europe and probably the world. I’m quite comfortable saying they were unlucky to lose—a draw at the least would’ve been more than fair on the night.

Villa created a number of good chances (five of them ‘big chances’), two of which were good enough to go in with better finishes. Finished on the front foot, broke well, and had some periods of sustained pressure. It reminded of the CL second leg, where PSG were confident and then rattled.

Villa were scrappy enough where it counted, and stayed well organized off the ball. Not much you can do about the first…turnover in a bad spot and nothing you can do about that finish. Their second…well, it’s a shame Matty wasn’t pushing up quite as quickly as the rest. Would’ve been interesting had that stayed 1-1 for longer. But Emery’s structure stayed intact despite the number of ‘new’ faces.

We were younger and quicker than last season and it showed. I thought Hemmings had impressed before, and he looked very comfortable out there. Not shy and very good on the ball. I’d like to see him make the squad. Alysson had a smaller part to play, and it’s a shame he and Tammy couldn’t connect there toward the end. When it comes to Gomes’ sample size, I thought that was a good outing.

Villa also did something which you can’t always say we do. With McGinn wide right, they kept pumping in crosses a la Messi in the WC Semi, and PSG struggled mightily. We found something they didn’t or couldn’t adapt to, and we kept at it. Lovely take from Madjo. Obviously given his size it’s hard to believe he’s just 17, but that was a quality finish that really belied his age.

I didn’t know whether winning that appeal was really going to be of any significance, but the kid certainly seems to have a future. Although he’s started regularly in the preseason with Ollie taking deserved time off, and has been scoring, I’d imagine Emery will bring him on slowly, probably as an impact sub like he did Duran. I can’t imagine him going on loan. He’s had his shot this preseason and he’s taken it. But you never know. While I might discount goals against an Indonesia XI, for example, you can’t dismiss scoring a cracker against PSG. The occasion did not seem too big for him in any way.

On another night, Buendia might’ve had a highlight or two. Maatsen did well enough, I thought, given the task. Overall, no one played poorly. Far from it. There were some nice interchanges and the right ideas, even when they didn’t come off.

So, no one ever likes losing, but given the players we’ve lost and the seemingly perpetual task of finding replacements, I think the performance has given everyone a lot of encouragement and rightly so.

Over to you.

Share:

PreviousFootball Integrity Doesn’t Exist
NextNew-Look Villa Enter New Era

About The Author

JC

John Clark

John Clark's alter ego

Related Posts

Carabao Crash-out

Carabao Crash-out

17.09.2025

New-Look Villa Enter New Era

New-Look Villa Enter New Era

23.08.2026

Gripes, Grumbles, Brentford and Palace

Gripes, Grumbles, Brentford and Palace

31.08.2025

Europa League Final: Freiburg vs. Villa

Europa League Final: Freiburg vs. Villa

20.05.2026

19 Comments

  1. PDXVillan
    PDXVillan on 13.08.2026 at 6:55 pm

    One competitive appearance and he’s being touted as Kane’s successor for England. Not much more one can say!

    In terms of replacing Rogers and Tielemans, there are no perfect, direct replacements. But Unai won’t expect one. We are already seeing him adapt the tactics to the players on the pitch, as with all the crosses that wouldn’t have worked with Ollie in the middle. Remember that Duran actually started ahead of Ollie for a stretch of matches in the spring of his last year at Villa. I expect that to happen with Madjo when Ollie goes into one of his semi-annual, month-long slumps. In terms of Tielemans’s role, I actually saw Barkley playing that role in some earlier friendlies this year, and laying it very well. I think he will get more minutes this season if he can stay healthy. We’ll have to see what Manzambi and Garnacho offer as Unai tweaks the system to play to their strengths.

    UTV

    Log in to Reply
    • JC
      JC on 14.08.2026 at 6:28 pm

      Yeah, if Barks can stay healthy he’s a very good player. But you’re right, there are no direct replacements and Emery’s had to adjust time and again with all the injuries.

      Log in to Reply
  2. Plug
    Plug on 14.08.2026 at 9:56 am

    Thanks for the write up John. Think you speak for all of us with your thoughts on the current situation at VP. Maybe I’m holding blind faith in Unai, but when there was £117m on the table for Rogers, I’d have taken it. Though Tielemans at £35m hurt. Nevertheless, I believe Unai will weld a team together this season and I’ve been unwavering in my belief that we’ll make the top 5 again and hopefully the UCL again. We now belong in that competition.

    All the noise around Madjo for me is just that, noise. We’ll have to see how he progresses. Don’t think for one moment Ollie will be worried about it but Tammy may be a different matter. I’ll reserve judgment on Manzambi until I see how he settles in after a run of games. Gomes has looked a very worthwhile acquisition as his performances increased with familiarity of the players around him.

    Hemmings had an excellent game against PSG. Will Unai keep him for the squad or loan him out? And is Ned ready to fight for the RB position with Cash? All will be answered by the end of the month. Seems the next incoming will be a LB replacement for Digne.

    Log in to Reply
    • JC
      JC on 14.08.2026 at 6:31 pm

      Agreed, too much money to ignore. I do hope he keeps Hemmings around. He seems ready. Madjo? Yeah, I don’t think we need to worry about whether he’s the next Kane or Lukaku just yet.

      Log in to Reply
  3. Plug
    Plug on 15.08.2026 at 1:38 pm

    Team news against Borussia Monchengladbach:

    Villa starting XI: Bizot; Nedeljkovic, Lindelof, Mings, Rowe; Bogarde, Barkley; Alysson, Lynch, Hemmings; Abraham.

    Subs: Wright, Asemota, Cash, McGinn, Kamara, Buendia, Torres, Jimoh-Aloba, Maatsen, Burrowes, Borland, Broggio.

    Log in to Reply
  4. Plug
    Plug on 15.08.2026 at 4:33 pm

    So it finished Borussia Monchengladbach 2-1 Villa. Having watched all pre season games live, I can safely say the first half of this one was the worst I’ve seen. We have to view it in light of the starting line up but Barks, Bogey, Rowe, Lynch, Hemmings and Tammy were all well below par and 2-0 at HT was not surprising.

    SJM pulled one back after HT following a slick move between Maatsen, Buendia and SJM.

    Log in to Reply
  5. PDXVillan
    PDXVillan on 15.08.2026 at 5:33 pm

    Pretty depressing first half. The kids have looked pretty impressive at times this summer, but seemingly only when a core of regulars are there to provide the structure.

    I think we have lost all of our friendlies against first-division European sides. Close matches, but not building my confidence.

    Log in to Reply
  6. JC
    JC on 16.08.2026 at 8:43 pm

    First half was rough, but good experience against a fast, high-pressure side. Thought there were a lot of niggly fouls…bit unnecessary for preseason. Second half much better.

    I do think you have to have that core in there to give the kids structure. One or two academy players is probably all you want to break in at a time.

    Log in to Reply
  7. Plug
    Plug on 17.08.2026 at 8:52 am

    So I wake up this morning to the news that WN1 move to Juventus is off. But the purchase of Suzuki is going ahead for 30m euros. WTF.

    Can only assume that when news broke on Saturday of Emi’s impending move, the man himself decided he did not wish to be employed in Turin. Who knows? Is he injured? No way he’s our No.2 keeper. We’ll watch this space with interest.

    Log in to Reply
    • JC
      JC on 17.08.2026 at 2:57 pm

      Dunno what to make of it, Plug. Seems like we’d been haggling with Juve over peanuts, based on what I’m reading. I’d think we have to get rid of Emi’s wages if nothing else.

      Log in to Reply
  8. Plug
    Plug on 19.08.2026 at 10:00 am

    Welcome to Villa Park Matteo Ruggeri and Zion Suzuki. You both join the project at exciting times and we wish you the very best.

    Log in to Reply
  9. Plug
    Plug on 19.08.2026 at 10:02 am

    Which leaves me wondering about WN1. Our Emi. What a purchase he has been for us. Assuming he will be moving on and we may have seen his final performance for Villa at Istanbul.

    Log in to Reply
  10. Plug
    Plug on 19.08.2026 at 4:27 pm

    What a monumental day. We’ve been informed of our 2 new signings. One of them means WN1 is leaving. Then we discover that Konsa to the Arse looks well advanced and Ollie may be heading to Saudi. The rebuild of our squad is happening before our eyes. Well fuck the financial regulations that created this uneven playing field.

    And whilst I’m in the mood, EPL chief Masters needs to be hauled over the coals about Citeh. Whenever he’s questioned on the matter he hides behind the process. He has some serious questions to answer like WHEN might we expect a decision? HOW MUCH is the legal bill currently standing at on this matter? WHERE might the legal bill end up costing the EPL teams? He’s been given a very easy ride on this matter.

    Log in to Reply
  11. henrydouble
    henrydouble on 20.08.2026 at 4:01 pm

    It could be a season of lower expectations with the forced rebuild, but I still see us as anything between 3rd and 8th. We have the best manager in the league.

    I’d see success as being in the top 10 all season, finishing in the top 24 in the Champion’s League, and please Paul McGrath, no more knee injuries.

    If all goes well, we will finish top 4 and Bouba will be the final SCR/PSR pawn in a move to Real Madrid.

    It’s a big season for the transfer committee, we need the majority of the signings to hit the ground running, because we don’t have anymore jokers left in our hand to play.

    Log in to Reply
  12. henrydouble
    henrydouble on 20.08.2026 at 4:41 pm

    And Brighton have a euro qualifier tonight, so maybe that will help us out

    Log in to Reply
  13. Plug
    Plug on 21.08.2026 at 5:14 pm

    Best wishes Ezri Konsa on your future career. You have been a wonderful soldier for us and will always be welcome at VP.

    Can’t say the same though for the outfit he has joined. They clearly tapped him up on England duty at the WC as his comments made today said as much. My dislike of the Arse has gone up several notches.

    Log in to Reply
    • JC
      JC on 21.08.2026 at 6:37 pm

      Yeah, I mean you win the CL and need to go out and buy how many players?

      Log in to Reply
  14. JC
    JC on 21.08.2026 at 6:44 pm

    I will wish Ezri the best, as well. I think Emery’s comments on Al Hilal’s relentless pursuit of Ollie says it all: If the price is right, the player wants the move and can be replaced, then we’ll do business. Every player has a price.

    So maybe this summer the Nicolas Jackson thing comes true. Not sure how I feel about that one, but Emery knows him, which has to count for something and if the papers are to be believed we’ve been trying to sign him since the end of the Cold War.

    Wan-Bissaka in on loan, which seems reasonable cover for Matty and the absence of Konsa deputizing there. Ruggeri obvs in to do the two LFB rotation Emery likes. Rumors of another midfielder, the Southampton CB to come in and fill out the CBs.

    All very interesting coming down to the wire. Don’t know that it was planned this way, as it seems certain sides have ‘forced’ our hand, but it’s turning out to be quite the overhaul.

    Log in to Reply
  15. JC
    JC on 23.08.2026 at 6:50 am

    Season arrives. New post up.

    Log in to Reply

Leave a reply Cancel reply

You must be logged in to post a comment.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Registration is free, so don't hesitate to join in. We don't sell anything, and cookies are set at the absolute functional minimum. Please see our Privacy Page for more information.

Login
Register
  1. Plug
    Plug on Hull 0-0 Aston Villa12.09.2026

    Overall, had no complaints about the result. We were on the ropes for the second half but did look like…

  2. Plug
    Plug on Hull 0-0 Aston Villa12.09.2026

    The two half time subs never worked for us. As noted by 656 and Henry, Tammy was not looking a…

  3. Plug
    Plug on Hull 0-0 Aston Villa12.09.2026

    Back from VP. Very disappointed. Glasner continues to hold the Indian Sign over Unai. First half reasonable, second half poor.…

  4. henrydouble
    henrydouble on Hull 0-0 Aston Villa12.09.2026

    Ignoring the final 15 when we were down to ten, it could be that 2 games a week was far…

  5. jbd656
    jbd656 on Hull 0-0 Aston Villa12.09.2026

    It was written in voodoo. A manager who can't stop beating us and a player who can't stop scoring against…

  • Hull 0-0 Aston Villa
  • New New-Look Villa
  • New-Look Villa Enter New Era
  • Ever-Changing Villa and Super Cup Optimism
  • Football Integrity Doesn’t Exist

Who’s Online

No one is online right now

Designed by Elegant Themes | Powered by WordPress

  • Login
  • AVL Blog
  • Match Previews
  • Match Reviews