I’d just about written off this match before kickoff for a number of reasons: all streaks end, we’ve been winning without playing particularly well, and Chelsea are a really tough match-up for us. Never mind that it was at Stamford Bridge. But apparently none of that mattered. Despite being smothered in the first 45 and giving up a soft goal, Villa roared back after the introduction of Watkins, Onana, and Sancho at 59 minutes, and Chelsea didn’t seem to know what to do. Watkins showed a lot of hunger to draw Villa level just four minutes later, and after that only one side looked like going on to win it.
The Tactics Question
In his post-match comments, Ollie credited Emery’s tactical genius, pointing to how the subs changed the set-up, particularly relative to Chelsea’s back line. Rogers and Sancho were deployed left and right yielding a bit more width, and Tielemans moving up gave Villa more four on three looks. That’s all very true, but it’s also not terribly different than what we’ve seen many times, with the exception of Sancho playing from the right.
When Onana and Kamara play together, Youri moves up. Rogers left is fairly common, and he thrives playing left to right. Sancho was the funny bit, having been, to my knowledge, only played on the left so far.
The slight stretching may have accounted for the space into which Ollie was played in to for his first, though it was Rogers providing service from a very central position. The second was simply a veteran striker registering a fine finish from a corner. It was also a lovely delivery. The spacing may well have been what opened things up for Maatsen’s effort.
So Emery didn’t really change formation. He simply shuffled to his preferred personnel package with the twist of Sancho wide right instead of someone like Guessand. And with Chelsea having run themselves ragged for 60 minutes and only finding themselves one goal to the good, Villa’s change of pace, intent, and quality turned the game.
Big and Small Thinking
That, to my mind, is where the real managing took place. I’d tuned in late (there’ve been some festivities in our home), and in conjunction with Chelsea winning everything, the broadcast team were focusing on Onana’s exclusion and maybe wondering why Malen got the start.
Me, I’m pretty sure Emery knew Chelsea were going to come at them, that’s what they do, and wanted Youri deeper to help us play out and start counters. Managing Onana’s minutes may also have come into it, same as Ollie. But if Emery figured the first 45 were going to be like Chelsea wanted, then weather the storm and keep your best attacking package in reserve for when there’s going to be more time and space.
But poor play is poor play. Villa didn’t handle the first-half pressure well, and I’m sure Emery isn’t looking for a string of dramatic comebacks. The idea is to at least keep a clean sheet in the conservative phase.
In the end, and I think by design, Villa had their best attacking side on the pitch after Chelsea had thrown everything at them, and also their best defensive midfield pairing.
Arsenal
After the match, the analysts, having finally clocked Emery’s game-management pattern, wondered if Arsenal might set up to account for this. They may very well. You could say Chelsea did in going for the knockout punch. It’s worked in the past. But, if you’re not pressing relentlessly, possession will be less lopsided, and you have a different kind of match. And Arsenal aren’t generally as aggressive as Chelsea. Funnily, a less one-sided opening half could to be to Arsenal’s advantage.
With Kamara and Cash suspended, there’ll be enforced changes. I’d assume that Bogarde comes in for Cash, which probably means Youri is deep again, this time with Onana. Emery will obviously have less to work with, so I’m imagining this will be game management of a different sort. You’d think Rogers comes back central, Sancho is left, McGinn right, and Ollie up top. Since they started Sunday, Buendia and Malen will be the fresh legs Emery can turn to.
I’m also guessing they’ll hope to keep the tempo down as per and get the most out of the starters following what seems to be a pretty consistent 60-30 distribution/rotation of minutes for Ollie, Buendia, Malen, and Sancho. I’d assume Digne starts. Guessand will be a miss in terms of subs. We are a touch thin
I’ve no idea what to expect from this one. Villa seem to play Arsenal well enough, but it’s away and there’s a lot more riding on it for them. That said, I usually like being the team under less pressure, and Arsenal have been far from convincing of late. I don’t think the streak is really too important to the players. I’m sure it’s been fun, winning always is, but it’s more that that they’re giving themselves a chance to return to the Champions League.
Intangibles
Obviously it was great to see Ollie finally break through. You get him back firing, and things suddenly look a tad more sustainable. While the first was scruffy, it showed his determination, and the first touch was back at the required level. The second, though, that’s the kind of finish from Ollie we’ve been missing, and it just looked and felt right.
And I thought the celebrations were telling. Rogers with Ollie’s shirt, Ollie joining Onana’s fun routine with a big smile. The players look together, and Ollie’s relief to finally be part of the party was tangible. I hope it bodes well for the future.
Over to you.
Another Comeback, Another Trip to London


Just another nagging reminder. We only need to beat the arse by 7 goals to go top. COYVB.
COYVB
I would also like to point out that Ollie was reserve C/F for England last January and Villa reportedly offered him to the arse. Seems like the club of his childhood dreams didn’t think he was worth the money.
Whatcha going to do about it Ollie?
And it’s your birthday!
Team news:
Martinez, Konsa, Lindelof, Digne, Bogarde, Onana, Tielemans, Rogers, Sancho, Buendia, Watkins
Subs: Bizot, Wright, McGinn, Garcia, Malen, Jimoh-Aloba, Maatsen, Hemmings, Routh
Bench looks a bit thin. Sancho starts and Bogey in too. No Rice for the Arse.
Well, got most of it right. Didn’t figure on Buenia for McGinn. A bit thin, yes.
Common sense team selection based on what’s available. Very noticeable how much of a song and dance has been made of arsenal’s available/un-available players for the last two months….nothing said that we have been missing Pau and Tyrone for ages, and only a comment in passing on Cash and Kamara.
As ever, the main stream don’t pick up any of the details from their pre-match cheat-sheet.
I’m sure I’ve heard more about Rice’s absence than anyone else’s.
Good enough…could’ve done a little better on a couple of the breaks, but overall not bad.
Agree with that. Nicking one of those counters (which didn’t quite yield any tap ins) would’ve been perfection. Hope we can keep 11 sprint-capable players on the pitch for the entire game.
Damn
Hmmmm – Martinez being a bit wimpy?
Yeah, not quite as assured, though I do think the arm put him off given Gabriel’s height.
Double damn
Not the best between Youri and Sancho there.
That should’ve been yellow again
Got to clear the lines
Galling
Had to end, but…
We didn’t take our chances in the first half and then gifted them theirs. Still a nice gap to Chelsea and Man United, and the first half was very good. This is an 11 that we would never choose to play, so we just have to learn the lessons and try to do better. Hope Onana isnt actually injured.
Yep, excellent up to HT despite missing a few chances on the break. Gutted with our second half showing. The loss of Onana was immense.
Well at least we don’t have to worry about maintaining that winning run. Glad to see some kids coming on. Let’s see if they have got anything.
Reminded me a little bit of the 4-2 a few years ago. With too many mistakes giving up goals. Good for the kids, even better to have Cash and Kamara back next.
Seems ironic to me that we had one of our better first halves in ages but then followed it up with our worst second half in aeons. Just shows that we could cover for losing 2 certain starters but losing a 3rd in Onano for the 2nd half was the proverbial straw. It’s conceivable that Onana’s size might have made a difference for THAT fumbled corner. We just didn’t have enough goods on the pitch to recover from that downer. Shows to me that like it or not, we will have to give Garcia some game time just to cover for Cash. Don’t think we can just get in a ready made RB during January.
Positives for me is that Garcia and the 2 acadamy kids got some game time. Slogging and burn out times are ahead and one of those kids might make a difference in one unexpected crunch game.
No POTM for me. That’s no criticism from me, it was finally just not our day. We will get our 2 guaranteed starters back for the next game. Who knows about Onana? Sadly all the media luvvies have had a good day. Perhaps we can go back under the radar and resume undermining those prats again. Come Easter, let’s see who wants to bet against us.
We got caught short on squad depth. Martinez at fault for the first goal, a replica of one a few days earlier at Chelsea. Teams now know a simple corner swung in on top of him pays huge dividends. He simply has to punch those clear. If he doesn’t change we’ll suffer more of them.
Thought Rogers looked gassed. He was invisible. But most of them looked the same. A game too far for us.
But Darren England was awful. Saka twice deliberately kicked the legs from under our players as they broke forward. Neither were carded. Morino did the same whilst he was already on a yellow. Extremely poor and biased refereeing.
Poor from Martinez (again) but I really think that he’s left with A LOT of work to do from corners. He’s like 80% of the corner defence. He usually has to fight off 2 players before the corner is taken. I don’t understand why he isn’t given a proper bodyguard.
I’ve been a bit forgetful. Credit to Malen for getting stuck into the entire arse defense and gifting Ollie a consolation goal to slightly hold up our faltering goal difference.
Yes, but how did SJM miss a massive open goal?
It was a fab Martinez style goal line save from Raya. I wouldn’t complain.
It now comes down to our reaction against Forest. We will have fresh legs in Maatsen, Cash and Kamara. Manure and Chelsea both burnt home games and dropped points so the damage was limited.
Overall, it has been a spectacular month. When the fixtures were published we looked at the month of December with fear and trepidation. Yet the points returns from those games have been unbelievable. Five out of the seven games away from home over a congested period with a small squad compared to the privileged teams granted an uneven playing field.
Yeah, what a run. One more game to go, then they get a rest. Very impressive output and I think the mentality has stepped up on this run. They seem locked in with an inner resolve. Hats off to the players and of course Don Unai.
Lots of good sense here. The run was always going to end, the bans did not come at a good time, Onana going out was quite the additional blow, and we split the season series with the arse.
I just really dislike Mikel and hope they bottle it again. If I had that much depth and talent I’d be a lot less of a dick.
That said, I do have to tip my hat to Trossard. I was loving those fleeting summer rumors that we were in for him. When he’s on, he’s on.
And it matters not a whit, but I did like the consolation goal for the lads not quitting. Arse took their foot off it a bit, maybe out of respect for Unai, but denying the clean sheet was still good.
Feeling nothing but pride this morning. The shysters that run the EPL stitched us up with the Dec fixtures. The governing bodies in England and Europe have developed a regulatory system to keep the playing field uneven and massively in favour of the “entitled” few. We battle against these odds…pedalling up hill, swimming up stream. So to be sitting 3rd in the table and 9 points ahead of Chelsea in P5 despite the above is exceptional by any metric.
Having played 10 big games in 37 days, we start with another run of 8 games in 29 days against Forest on Sat. All this congestion caused by the plain greed of the governing bodies shoe horning in more unwanted games to grasp as much $$$$ as possible. Which in turn means teams need bigger squads and which in turn makes the playing field even more uneven due to SCR’s.
My view is the money grabbers must ultimately kill the goose that lays the golden egg. I’ve already witnessed half empty stadiums across Europe when watching highlights of various UCL and Europa matches. Sponging the supporters has reached saturation levels and televised games can now be low on atmosphere and therefore attraction. The game is broken.
What a calendar year,hopefully our finances have improved enough especially without 35m for elliot to get a couple new faces in January, we really need to be buying physical imposing lads at that
Defeat last night boiled down to shocking officials plus var,first goal gogkes was 3 yards offside from move corner they scored from no flag from lino,merino has been mentioned numerous time along with sako,big damian emery best pal has to keep the media spotlight on these occurrences
We go again Saturday with only who plays in front 4 along with mcginn rogers and watkins
Tuned into Gabon v Ivory Coast (out of sheer boredom) in the 60th minute just as Guessand came on with Ivory Coast 2-1 down. Cue a towering header from our very own African squad player to equalise then inspire a late 3-2 win.
Will he come back inspired or knackered?
Ha…If those are the choices I’ll vote inspired. He can hardly be knackered.
Welcome to VP Alysson. Here’s hoping your stay is successful.
I know little about this winger so we’ll have to wait and see how he develops.
So Unai has said “we don’t want buy Harvey Elliott permanently for £35m”. That puts to bed the previous theory that it was for UEFA SCR and he’d play in 2026. I guess there are a limited number of options now. Liverpool won’t give up their leverage and recall him without some money (at least his wages for the rest of the season) and Villa aren’t going to play him and run down the 5 game buffer. Maybe Liverpool will drop the obligation to buy, so we can play him. I can’t see Harvey moving to America. One extra bit of leverage for Villa is that this is a problem for the relationship between Harvey and Liverpool. So they will have some motivation to sort something out, especially if they want to re-try selling him in 6 months.
For us it probably means not being able to pull the trigger until late in January, after everything is sorted.
Also just looking at where the value is, it’s £35m to sign Harvey Elliott, conversely, Harry Wilson is available on a free in July. Lindelöf has been a brilliant free, and maybe we can pull another one out. There are a few decent players out of contract who could be great squad players. Adama Traore is another.
Yeah, we’ve done well on the frees.
Going to trust Emery on Elliott. Strange situation, feel bad for the player, but we have to be so careful. For 35m, I’m thinking we can fill a bigger need.
I wonder how much he might play even if Liverpool remove the obligation. Guessing he’s learned things by now, another body, but.
If only Ollie…………………………….
Ollie stinger from just outside the box. a perfect final kick of the half.
I was about to grumble about a typical slow ponderous overcomplicated typical Villa first half performance – then Ollie just gives the ball some wellie from out of the blue. You can play next game if you want to.
One nil up. Playing to the Holte End. What could possibly go wrong?
Tippy tappy bish bosh SJM goal.
Unmarked Gibbs White allowed to run through for a goal. Complacent Villa!
Gift from forrest goalie. T’mans spots SJM half way in forrest half. Long range curling crawler from SJM into empty goal.
Very weird seeing Dougie coming on for forrest!
Fairly comfortable half paced energy conserving win for Villa. Wish we could have boosted our goal difference a bit more.
Can’t really pick a POTM. T’mans for pulling most of the strings? SJM for a typically busy performance and 2 eye catching goals? Kamara for being effortlessly smooth?
Next game shouldn’t be too hard should it?
You’re better than my ESPN app, jbd!
Welcome to my blog JC! You can stay if you like – I need to conserve my energy for next grudge Wednesday.
Ha! Love it.
Very early KO here…woke up, 2-0 Villa, fed the cat, made coffee, looked and it was 2-1. Was recording, but thought I should now tune in. Less than a minute later, SJM gets his second, job done.
So yeah, bit of a howler from their keeper, but I’m going to step into the frame for that one.
(Was also a much trickier finish than it first looked. Really composed curl off that left peg.)
Have to applaud the lads…another short turn, did well to pick themselves up. Just from the highlights, three quality goals.
Loved Ollie’s screamer, so important he’s feeling good again. SJM, great getting into the box (per instruction, apparently) for the second, then a beautiful ball and a very neat finish.
This stretch has been really tough and remarkable. Giving themselves every chance.
WE’VE GOT MCGINN………SUPER JOHN MCGINN………
Just thawing out after freezing my nuts off at VP. We could have got off to a flyer at the start but Ollie failed to convert or maybe the keeper did well. Dunno. Then we were presented to a very passive Forest performance. Most unlike Dyche, I was expecting a battle. Right on HT, boom, Ollie smashes in the opener from outside the box which unfroze the crowd.
Straight after HT SJM ignited the ground with a slick finish. Getting 2-0 up from a training ground performance was creditable but you just know, when Villa go 2 goals ahead, the busiest man thereafter will be our keeper. Our game management leaves me cold. Citeh do it by passing the ball around their opponents box, we do it by passing the ball around our box. We invite pressure and let them back in with a goal. Maybe Unai is fearful of the counter attack.
But T’mans who I thought had a quiet game produced a sublime pass forward to SJM. Their keeper went AWOL and SJM gleefully accepted the empty onion bag. Cue much joy and ecstasy.
Another 3 points accrued. It will be interesting to see the gap to P5 after match week 20 concludes. Top weekend assured.
With the injuries, thought our bench looked a bit thin. It’s just as well Forest’s minds might have been on their midweek game at West ‘Aaamm.
Also thought Hooper gave a poor refereeing performance. Several times in the first half our players were forcibly pushed from behind inside the penalty area but he wasn’t ever going to give us a penalty. The second half kicks off and their LB goes down in his own area from the slightest of touches and gets a free kick. This type of inconsistency fries my brain.
Kamara grew into the game as it became more open when Forest were forced to attack more. The World’s No 1 actually punched a corner clear! Signs they’ve finally grasped that issue. And SJM popped up with 2 goals to make my weekend.
I like that we’re getting goals rotated round. They need to feel more than one can step up.
Match week 20 completed and we’re 11 points clear of P5. This week’s results have been excellent for us. Looking at various games it seemed obvious to me that most teams are treading water due to fixture congestion. There’s also a proper scrap unfolding below us with 10 teams fighting for P5 separated by just 4 points. Lot’s of incentive to move quite a few places upwards and fear of quite a few places below them. Should make it very competitive down there and help our cause.
It was a good weekend, so much happening. Maresco, Amorim out, Slot tipped for the sack, never mind all the scrapping for points that you note.
And there’s a fresh page up